If the defendant introduces evidence of insanity, must the prosecution prove sanity beyond a reasonable doubt? Discuss the various rules. How do you feel about the insanity defense? Should it be abolished? Why or why not?


In criminal law, the insanity defense is a legal doctrine that allows defendants to argue that they should not be held criminally responsible for their actions because of a mental illness or defect at the time of the offense. The rules regarding the burden of proof for insanity defenses vary depending on the jurisdiction and legal system. Here are the main approaches:

  1. M’Naghten Rule: Originating from the 1843 case of M’Naghten, this rule focuses on whether the defendant knew the nature and quality of their actions or understood that their actions were wrong. Under the M’Naghten Rule, if the defendant was unable to understand the nature and quality of their actions or did not know that their actions were wrong due to a mental illness or defect, they may be found not guilty by reason of insanity. In jurisdictions that follow this rule, the burden is typically on the defense to prove insanity by a preponderance of the evidence.
  2. Irresistible Impulse Test: This test expands upon the M’Naghten Rule by considering whether the defendant had the ability to control their actions due to a mental illness or defect. If the defendant was unable to control their actions despite understanding that they were wrong, they may be found not guilty by reason of insanity. In jurisdictions that apply this test, the burden of proof may still rest with the defense to prove insanity by a preponderance of the evidence.
  3. Model Penal Code Test: Some jurisdictions have adopted the Model Penal Code’s approach to insanity, which focuses on whether the defendant lacked substantial capacity to appreciate the criminality of their conduct or to conform their conduct to the requirements of the law. Under this test, if the defendant’s mental illness or defect impaired their cognitive or volitional capacities to the extent that they could not appreciate the wrongfulness of their actions or conform their conduct to the law, they may be found not guilty by reason of insanity. The burden of proof may vary by jurisdiction, but it often rests with the defense to prove insanity by clear and convincing evidence.
  4. Burden on the Prosecution: In a few jurisdictions, if the defendant introduces evidence of insanity, the burden shifts to the prosecution to prove the defendant’s sanity beyond a reasonable doubt. This approach places a higher burden on the prosecution to negate the defense of insanity.

As for my personal opinion on the insanity defense, I believe it serves an important purpose in the criminal justice system. Mental illness can significantly impair an individual’s ability to understand the consequences of their actions or to conform their behavior to the law. Holding individuals criminally responsible for acts committed while experiencing severe mental illness may not serve the interests of justice or public safety. However, I also recognize that the insanity defense can be subject to abuse or manipulation, and it is essential to ensure that it is used appropriately and fairly.

As for whether the insanity defense should be abolished, I do not believe it should be eliminated entirely. Instead, I think there should be ongoing efforts to refine and improve the criteria and procedures for determining insanity. This may include implementing stricter standards for proving insanity, providing better access to mental health treatment and evaluations, and ensuring that individuals found not guilty by reason of insanity receive appropriate treatment and supervision. Ultimately, the goal should be to balance the need for accountability and public safety with compassion and recognition of the complex interplay between mental illness and criminal behavior.

Calculate the price
Make an order in advance and get the best price
Pages (550 words)
*Price with a welcome 15% discount applied.
Pro tip: If you want to save more money and pay the lowest price, you need to set a more extended deadline.
We know how difficult it is to be a student these days. That's why our prices are one of the most affordable on the market, and there are no hidden fees.

Instead, we offer bonuses, discounts, and free services to make your experience outstanding.
How it works
Receive a 100% original paper that will pass Turnitin from a top essay writing service
step 1
Upload your instructions
Fill out the order form and provide paper details. You can even attach screenshots or add additional instructions later. If something is not clear or missing, the writer will contact you for clarification.
Pro service tips
How to get the most out of your experience with Boom Grades
One writer throughout the entire course
If you like the writer, you can hire them again. Just copy & paste their ID on the order form ("Preferred Writer's ID" field). This way, your vocabulary will be uniform, and the writer will be aware of your needs.
The same paper from different writers
You can order essay or any other work from two different writers to choose the best one or give another version to a friend. This can be done through the add-on "Same paper from another writer."
Copy of sources used by the writer
Our college essay writers work with ScienceDirect and other databases. They can send you articles or materials used in PDF or through screenshots. Just tick the "Copy of sources" field on the order form.
See why 20k+ students have chosen us as their sole writing assistance provider
Check out the latest reviews and opinions submitted by real customers worldwide and make an informed decision.
english comp
Great paper and done before the deadline. Thank you
Customer 452509, June 15th, 2021
Public Health
Thank you so much !!
Customer 452589, November 28th, 2023
Absolutely LOVE having help especially from the person who wrote this last one. THANK YOU
Customer 452529, November 19th, 2021
Thank you so much this looks great !!!!
Customer 452585, November 4th, 2023
Classic English Literature
Absolutely LOVE the essay I received. I really appreciate it so much.
Customer 452529, October 25th, 2021
world civilization
Thank you for the quick response
Customer 452509, June 27th, 2021
english comp
Thank you for all your hard time.
Customer 452509, June 27th, 2021
Great content.
Customer 452549, February 8th, 2022
English comp
Got a 94% thank you!
Customer 452509, June 27th, 2021
Classic English Literature
Great Work as Usual. Thank you . I received an A on the paper!
Customer 452531, November 9th, 2021
Classic English Literature
Awesome Job... you are the best!
Customer 452531, November 27th, 2021
English 101
perfect! thanks!
Customer 452543, December 1st, 2021
Customer reviews in total
Current satisfaction rate
3 pages
Average paper length
Customers referred by a friend
15% OFF your first order
Use a coupon FIRST15 and enjoy expert help with any task at the most affordable price.
Claim my 15% OFF Order in Chat